Posts Tagged ‘Scotland’


At some point in the next four years we are certain to see a referendum on Scottish Independence. Will that vote be the end of the United Kingdom?

No. The United Kingdom remains as strong an institution as it has ever been. Devolution, a process started and finished by the last Labour Government has ensured that the outcome in that referendum will be a “no” vote. Now that there is a Tory – Liberal Government in Westminster, which will inflict spending cuts which will disproportionally affect Scotland a vote for independence would seem to be inevitable.

That would be true, if it were not for the Scotland Act, Devolution and the Scottish Parliament. These institutions allow Scots to protect themselves from a relatively hostile Westminster Government. Alex Salmond is the man that Scots have supported in this difficult time for Scotland. The Scottish National Party, having won an overall majority in the Scottish Parliament after an election in which they barely mentioned independence for Scotland. The SNP must be careful not to be overly hubristic after their success. They have one a victory. They will not win another in the fight for the future of the United Kingdom. As things stand, the Scottish public are overwhelmingly against independence. This will only potentially change for one reason.

The Conservative and Unionist Party.

If that Party now uses Scotland as a way of meeting their targets for spending cuts, they may be the force that causes the Union to collapse. Of course, the smart move politically would be for the Tories to support Scottish Independence. At the last General Election, Labour won 41 of Scotland’s 59 Westminster seats. Without those seats, Labour would have only just won a majority in the House of Commons in 2005. Scotland has been called the “Jewel in Labour’s Crown”. The Tories could never win in Scotland. They could however, stop Labour from winning. The Tories could easily find themselves in a position where they could rob Labour of that Jewel, and Crown forever. Labour as a governing Party could be consigned to the history books. Scottish independence would be significantly less advantageous for Scotland than having a national Labour Government. A Scottish Government would find it near impossible to maintain valuable Scottish services such as the NHS at their current levels. Devolution will protect Scotland in the years to come. Independence would destroy it.

For Labour to win the next General Election, and for Scotland to maintain it’s standing the Union must remain intact.

Read Full Post »

Alex Salmond has provoked fury with a scathing attack on the United Kingdom Supreme Court.

Both he and Kenny McAskill, the Scottish Justice Secratary have accused the Court of “intervening aggressively” in Scotland’s affairs. Kenny McAskill is seeking to cut off the £500,000 funding that the UKSC receives from Scotland each year. On the Newsnight programme in Scotland, which can be viewed here, Salmond said:

“I don’t think it’s sensible, fair or reasonable in any jurisdiction where we’ve a situation where one judge is overruling the opinion of many judges in another court,”

“It boils down to the potential replacement of Scottish law by Lord Hope’s law. I don’t think that’s a satisfactory situation.”

Lord Colin Boyd QC, a former lord advocate under the last Labour coalition government in Edinburgh and a legal adviser to the current UK government, said the supreme court had a clear and necessary role to protect fundamental legal rights. He told the Guardian that the  Scottish government was pursuing a “nationalist agenda”.

“I’m proud of the Scottish system as a Scottish lawyer, but legal systems have to grow and develop and serve the people – they’re not there as totems for nationalists,” he said.

“We have to abide by the highest international standards, and if that means that notions of civil and human rights come from elsewhere, my view is that it enriches Scottish law, rather than diminishes it.

“It would be better as a country – and that is the legislature, the government and the courts – if we ensured that we actually have a modern legal system that is fit for purpose.”

Salmond has attracted criticism from across the legal community with an attack on Lord Rodger and Lord Hope, the two Scottish Judges on the United Kingdom Supreme Court. 

Read Full Post »